Isn’t that Cute? By any other Name


Earlier today I ran across a photo article that addresses the ins and outs of photographing street people.

In the 1930s Doretha Lange b/w photography, photo-ed many of the down and out, those going through the Great Depression.

Often highlighting Church efforts with those deemed disadvantaged, we’ll see a poster punctuating a person struggling with life.  Many times this is usually a hungry child with a grossly distended stomach, or on other occasions a black and white child touching hands as the good church people hand offer a fresh baked cookie.

Still at other times, we love to zoom in on the homeless.  Photo instructions say NOT to ask them to smile. If you think I’m kidding about this:

https://digital-photography-school.com/tips-for-taking-street-portraits-lessons-learned-in-india/

So then, by now you’d probably like to know where I’m going with all of this. And what I’m actually doing here is expressing outrage over our fascination with people who are in great desperation, pain and suffering.

Who do we think we are?  What the hell do we think we’re doing?  Are we at a zoo and we’re examining the animals for a pet project? I have written this before:  there is no such thing as a homeless person.  Yes, we have PEOPLE who are homeless! Nonetheless, they are PEOPLE FIRST and homeless among an entirely different line.

People are NOT clients.  People are NOT patients, or wards, or specimens, or data, or a host of any other stupid thing we dare call them.

And no, no and hell no.  It isn’t cute.  NO!  A person suffering is not adorable for us to put in our National Geographic Magazines.  I’m going to say it again:  NO, NO, and Hell NO.

By any other name, agony is horrific.  It is terrible.  Loneliness is intolerable!  The feeling of isolation and rejection is crucifying.  We can label people, photograph them and make adorable pictures for us to admire: to ooh and ahh over, but by any other name, it is NOT cute.  It is BAD !

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Isn’t that Cute? By any other Name

    1. Yes, I do know that. They have the perspective the rest of us strive for, or tell ourselves we strive for. Not saying they are all saints, but they do have that perspective to say the least.

      Liked by 1 person

  1. I just shared this article (https://clevelandmagazine.com/cleader/community/articles/faces-of-the-nameless) with an ex the other day, saying I wanted to do this 10 years ago but couldn’t because the guys always got the wrong idea. I can’t tell you how many times homeless men asked me out when I worked downtown. One asked me for money and then came back to my sidewalk table 10 minutes later to ask me on a date. I used to talk to one guy, Charles, who I will undoubtedly mention in my memoir at some point, every day before and/or after work. After several weeks of talking and giving him whatever food I’d brought for myself for lunch, he laced his arm through mine, began walking me to my parking lot, and then told me to stand still. He’d bought himself a disposable camera and wanted to take my picture. :\
    All of that being said, I wanted to tell their story — however they wanted to tell it. Charles was intelligent, funny, and SO full of life, so I always wondered how he wound up on the street.
    I don’t know why people would just want to take their picture…? (Then again, *heavy sigh,* I don’t know why people do a lot of things. Like starting the so-called bum fight thing years ago, for example…)
    I appreciate your passion for wanting to help them by speaking up for them.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s